Introduction
Immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) have revolutionized the therapeutic landscape for a range of advanced malignancies, including non-small cell lung cancer and urothelial cancer, marking a significant shift in the treatment of conditions previously considered unresponsive to existing therapies [1]. This innovation extends to the field of dermatologic surgery, where agents such as pembrolizumab, nivolumab, and ipilimumab have become integral in management of advanced malignant melanoma. Unfortunately, adverse events related to such immune modulation, known as immune-related adverse events (irAEs), encompass a broad spectrum of adverse effects affecting multiple organ systems as a result of activation of immune pathways.
The most common irAEs are fatigue and dermatological conditions such as erythema, with symptomatology varying based on the specific ICI used [1]. Manifestations resembling rheumatoid conditions are noted in 1%–10% of patients treated with ICIs, whereas vasculitis is considerably less common [2]. This report describes a case in which lower leg ulcers developed as a rare manifestation of vasculitis in the context of ICI therapy, underscoring the critical need for awareness and understanding of this potential complication. Consent was acquired from the patient for the use of his images and data in this case report.
Case
The patient was a 70-year-old man under the care of the department of plastic and reconstructive surgery, diagnosed with malignant melanoma on his left great toe. Three years earlier, he had undergone wide local excision of the primary lesion along with dissection of the left inguinal lymph nodes. Histopathology confirmed malignant melanoma with more than 1% PD-L1 expression and no evidence of BRAF mutation.
ICI therapy with pembrolizumab was initiated 2 months postoperatively as adjuvant treatment. The patient received 12 cycles at 200 mg every 3 weeks, with an escalated dose of 400 mg for the 13th and 14th cycles. Six months into the therapy, intransit metastases developed on the ipsilateral thigh. Despite repeated local excisions and ongoing pembrolizumab treatment, including an increased dosage, the lesion remained uncontrolled.
Subsequently, due to apparent resistance to pembrolizumab, the treatment was replaced with a combination of nivolumab 80 mg and ipilimumab 200 mg. After two cycles of this regimen, growth of the local lesion was arrested. Unfortunately, the patient’s treatment course was complicated by development of colitis and pneumonitis, suggesting irAEs.
A trial of dacarbazine was undertaken but was soon discontinued because of lack of efficacy, leading to cessation of all pharmacological treatments. Palliative radiation therapy was then initiated.
Given the previous partial response, in consultation with oncologists, the patient elected to retry nivolumab and ipilimumab combination therapy. However, following two additional cycles, the irAEs recurred, necessitating discontinuation of the ICIs. In the third year following the initial surgery, and within 5 weeks following the second additional cycle, multiple poorly demarcated purpura with elevated lesions appeared on the contralateral side. These lesions had not been present at 4 weeks from the completion of the second cycle. Therefore, a punch biopsy was performed (Fig. 1A and B). The biopsy revealed neutrophilic infiltration around dermal vessels, extravasation of red blood cells within dermal collagen fibers, and nuclear dust. These findings are characteristic of leukocytoclasis, which is a hallmark of the pathological diagnosis of leukocytoclastic vasculitis (LCV) (Fig. 2). No melanoma markers or autoantibodies were detected by immunohistochemistry. The LCV was clinically attributed to ICI therapy.
Discussion
ICIs function as antagonists targeting CTLA-4 or PD-1 receptors. CTLA-4 is an inhibitory receptor on T lymphocytes and downregulates the immune response [3]. Similarly, PD-1 interacts with its ligands, PD-L1 and PD-L2, to modulate the immune system [3]. By inhibiting these receptors, ICIs can potentiate the activity of T lymphocytes against malignant neoplasms, albeit with an increased risk of provoking autoimmune disorders [1]. Common skin involvement, accounting for more than 30% of irAEs and presenting as maculopapular rash, dermatitis, itching, and depigmentation, is generally mild and does not require cessation of therapy [4,5]. In contrast, vasculitis, a rare irAE with a frequency of less than 1%, typically requires discontinuation of ICIs [6].
Daxini et al. [7] have documented that ICI-associated vasculitis can involve vessels of any size and that the onset can vary significantly from the first to 15th cycle of treatment, with a median onset of 3 months.
LCV results from deposition of immune complexes in small venules of the skin and is triggered by various factors, including infections, medications, microorganisms, viruses, autoantibodies, and chronic hepatitis [8]. It typically manifests as palpable purpura located primarily in the upper layers of the skin in gravity-dependent areas, such as the lower limbs, buttocks, and back, while internal organ involvement is rare [8].
Characteristic pathological features of LCV include deposition of multinucleated white blood cells, extravasation of red blood cells, fibrinoid necrosis, and leukocytoclasis (i.e., nuclear dust formed from destruction of multinucleated cells) [8].
The differential diagnosis includes paraneoplastic vasculitis, which is vasculitis occurring in association with malignant neoplasms, particularly hematologic cancers [1]. This type of vasculitis often develops within a year of cancer diagnosis and frequently involves the skin [9].
In our case, LCV may have developed in response to factors such as infection, medication, or malignancy. In terms of medication history, the patient was taking gabapentin, a calcium channel blocker, a proton pump inhibitor, apixaban, nicorandil, tamsulosin, and steroids; however, none of these medications had been recently initiated. Serological tests for hepatitis virus were negative, and no other findings indicative of bacterial infection were observed. An autoantibody screen for autoimmune disease was negative. Despite thorough pathological evaluation, immune complexes, which were suspected as a causative factor, were not identified. According to Sams [10], the pathology of this condition is markedly dynamic, and the window for accurately identifying the immune cause is confined to 18–24 hours after onset of symptoms. Samples obtained too soon might not reflect the relevant changes, while those obtained after this critical period may have undergone phagocytosis, rendering the true etiology elusive in a clinical setting.
In our case, based on the clinical history and presentation, we concluded that the LCV was an irAE induced by nivolumab and ipilimumab. Consequently, these agents were discontinued, and immunosuppressive therapy with steroids was initiated. The actual onset of the irAE is presumed to have occurred in the 5th week after the completion of the second cycle of combination therapy. The ulcers did not recur following treatment. The clinical course further indicated that the ulcers were a result of vasculitis as an irAE. Consistent with other literature, cessation of ICIs and the initiation of steroids were necessary for treatment [5,6,11-13]. Additional immunosuppressive therapy may also be warranted depending on the severity and progression of the patient’s response [11].
While this case contributes important clinical observations regarding the irAEs of ICI therapy, its findings are limited by the constraints of a single case study. The direct causality between the ICIs and LCV, though suggested by clinical outcomes, remains hypothetical without further corroborative studies. Future research with larger subject groups is necessary to validate these conclusions.
In conclusion, given the growing indications for ICIs and their growing prevalence in the treatment of various types of malignancy, it is anticipated that there will be an increase in the incidence of ulcers induced by these agents. As pathology alone may not pinpoint the etiology, meticulous history-taking that includes the timing of symptom onset, medication history, and accompanying illnesses is imperative for accurate diagnosis of the cause of the ulcers.